Banana Split Cake

Banana Split Dump Cake takes the traditional ice cream favorite and turns it into a cozy, warm treat featuring caramelized bananas, sweet pineapple chunks, and juicy strawberries under a crispy, buttery top. What makes this dessert special is how it's built in layers – fruit juice soaking up from the bottom, crunchy cake on top, and all the yummy toppings you'd find on the classic sundae. Unlike fancier desserts that need exact measurements, this easy treat turns out great even if you're not perfect, and every bite is packed with amazing flavor.

The first time I whipped this up was for a backyard cookout when I needed something quick but impressive. My kitchen smelled amazing with fruity sweetness and buttery goodness filling the air. What really got me was seeing everyone's reaction with each bite – that wow moment when they tasted something familiar in a totally new way. Even my brother-in-law, who usually skips dessert completely, came back for another helping and asked how to make it.

Fruity Foundation

• Super ripe bananas: They get extra sweet when baked and add a caramel-like flavor throughout. Go for ones with dark spots for the best taste.
• Bright strawberries: They add nice color and a bit of tang that cuts through the sweetness. Pick completely red ones for better flavor.
• Crushed pineapple with juice: Brings tropical flavor and needed wetness to the bottom of the cake. Its sourness helps balance the rich stuff around it.
• Yellow cake mix: Makes a perfect golden top without any fuss or measuring. The powder works its magic during baking.
• Butter: Turns the cake mix into a crunchy, tasty topping. Pick unsalted so you can control how salty your dessert turns out.
• Heavy whipping cream: Adds fluffy softness to the dense cake with a hint of creamy flavor. It gives a nice contrast to the fruit underneath.

Layering Magic

Fruit Foundation:

Cut ripe bananas into circles and place them across your greased pan in one layer. They'll turn super sweet while baking, creating little pockets of yummy goodness throughout. Dump the whole can of pineapple with all its juice on top, making sure it covers everything so each bite has that tangy tropical taste.

Berry Brilliance:

Remove the green tops from strawberries, slice them up, and toss them all over the pineapple. The berries will get soft but keep their shape, adding bright red spots and jammy sweetness. Their slight sourness works really well with the super sweet stuff in the rest of the dessert.

Cake Creation:

Shake the dry cake mix all over the fruit, making an even blanket of powder. Don't mix it in – keeping everything separate is what makes dump cakes so special with their different textures. The dry mix will soak up fruit juice from below while baking.

Butter Blessing:

Drizzle melted butter over the cake mix, trying to cover as much as you can. Any dry spots will stay powdery instead of turning into the yummy crust you want. Take your time here – this step creates that awesome contrast between the wet fruit bottom and crunchy, buttery top.

Golden Perfection:

Put your cake in the hot oven and bake until the top turns golden and the edges bubble with fruit juice. When you see this happening, you'll know the cake mix has soaked up the butter and made a crust while the fruits below have mixed together and released their juices.

Pin it

I've always loved anything banana split flavored because my grandpa would buy me ice cream every weekend after we went to church. He always picked the classic banana split, and he'd share bites with me from each section. When I first made this dump cake version, I called him right away to tell him about it. At 92 years old, he tried making it himself and told me it was "better than the original" – which meant a lot coming from someone who really knows his banana splits!

Perfect Pairings

This easy dessert fits right in at all kinds of meals, casual or fancy. For family dinner, serve it a little warm with some vanilla ice cream on top that slowly melts into the cake. When friends come over, dish it up in nice bowls topped with fresh whipped cream and some chocolate sauce drizzled over for a fancier look. In summertime, set it out next to a coffee station with different flavored creamers that go well with the sweet fruitiness.

Creative Twists

Switch up this simple recipe by trying different fruits based on what's in season. Maybe swap strawberries for blueberries or blackberries to get deeper flavors and pretty purple-blue colors. If you like coconut, sprinkle some shredded coconut on the cake mix before adding butter to give everything a tropical taste. Make a chocolate version by using chocolate cake mix instead of yellow and throwing in some chocolate chips between the fruit and cake for melty pockets of goodness.

Fresh Forever

Keep leftover cake in the fridge with a cover on it for up to four days, though it changes a bit as it gets cold. The cake part becomes more like pudding and the fruit flavors get stronger, making it just as yummy but different. Warm up single servings in the microwave for about 25 seconds if you want the original warm feeling, or eat it cold straight from the fridge for a cool summer treat. If you need to make it ahead, put everything together except the whipped cream up to a day early, keep it in the fridge, then bake it right before you want to serve it.

After making dump cakes for years, I've learned how flexible and forgiving they really are. This banana split version has become my go-to dish for potlucks, and everyone always asks me to bring it. There's something special about taking simple ingredients and creating a dessert that makes people so happy and reminds them of childhood treats. The mix of warm fruity bottom and cool creamy toppings gives you the perfect balance of temperatures and textures that keeps everyone digging in for just a little bit more.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can frozen fruits be used here?

Sure! Thaw and drain frozen strawberries before using, and stick with fresh bananas since frozen ones get too mushy. Fresh fruit toppings will look and taste the best.

→ What if I don't have all the fruits?

It's super flexible! Try swapping strawberries for cherries or raspberries, or skip an ingredient. Using just bananas and pineapples is still delicious.

→ Can I prep this ahead?

Go ahead and bake the base a day early and cover it to store at room temperature. Just hold off on whipped cream and fresh fruit till you're ready to serve.

→ How can you tell it’s baked fully?

It’s ready when the top turns golden and firm, with bubbling juices around the edges. If it browns too fast, cover it loosely with foil so it cooks through.

→ How can I make it dairy-free?

Swap butter for melted coconut oil or a plant-based alternative, and use dairy-free cake mix. Coconut whipped cream makes a great substitute for topping. Always check ingredients!