Carrot Cake Cheesecake Layer

I found this honeybun carrot cake creation last year during my Easter dinner prep search. The mix of soft carrot cake with that hidden cheesecake layer and that cinnamon-filled cream cheese topping makes a mind-blowing treat that feels like you're eating carrot cake and cinnamon rolls at once. It's now my favorite for those times when I want folks to be really wowed.

My husband's mom, who rarely likes any sweets, grabbed the recipe after just one taste. She told me it was the tastiest carrot cake she'd ever had, which meant everything coming from someone who bakes as well as she does.

Top-Notch Components

• Whole carrots - Grab a grater and do it by hand for the ideal feel, though you can use your food processor if you're rushed
• Sour cream - This sneaky add-in is why the cake stays super soft
• Cream cheese - Don't skimp with low-fat stuff - go all in for both the middle and top layers
• Brown sugar - Makes everything richer and wetter than regular white sugar could
• Cinnamon - Shows up in both cake parts and topping to nail that honeybun taste

Pin it

Baking Magic

Getting Carrots Ready

Carrots you just grated work wonders in this cake. I grab the smaller holes on my box grater for just the right size - not too big, not too small. The wetness from fresh carrots helps make that super soft texture carrot cakes need. Those pre-shredded bags from the store are usually too dry and bulky for good results. I've learned that grating right before mixing keeps all the juice and flavor locked in. Two cups seems like overkill, but it's exactly what you need for this cake.

Making Your Mix

This oil-based mix works differently than butter cakes. When you mix sugars with oil, you won't see it get fluffy like with butter, and that's totally fine. The trick is adding eggs one by one to get everything blended right. I stir in the carrots and sour cream with a spoon instead of my mixer so I don't overdo it. Your batter should be thick but still pourable - this keeps the cheesecake part firmly in the middle instead of dropping down.

Creating The Middle Layer

Your cream cheese must be really soft to avoid lumps in the filling. I let mine sit out two hours, or unwrap and zap it for 20 seconds when I'm in a hurry. Beat it alone first until it's super smooth before anything else goes in. This filling should spread easily but still hold its shape. I use a flat spatula to spread it on the first cake layer, stopping a bit from the edges so it won't touch the pan sides, helping it stay centered while it bakes.

Putting It All Together

For splitting the carrot cake mix, I put about a third on the bottom rather than half, leaving plenty for a good top cover over the cheesecake. When adding that last bit of mix, I drop spoonfuls carefully over the cheesecake and slowly spread it out, trying not to mess up what's underneath. If some cheesecake peeks through, that's okay - it'll make cool swirls in your finished cake. The main thing is making sure most of the cheesecake has cover to protect it while baking.

Nailing The Bake Time

How long it bakes changes based on your oven and pan sizes. The toothpick check works, but I also look for other clues: the cake pulling back from the pan edges, the top bouncing back when you touch it, and no wiggling in the middle when you move the pan. I start checking at 25 minutes, though 30-35 usually works best. If the edges brown too fast before the middle's done, I wrap them loosely with foil.

Cooling Down Right

Good cooling matters tons for this cake. I keep the layers in their pans about 15 minutes, then flip them onto cooling racks to finish. Trying to frost a warm cake turns into a mess - your frosting melts and layers slide around. For best results, I actually chill the layers in the fridge for an hour after they cool to room temp. This firms up the cheesecake center and makes frosting much easier without getting crumbs in your icing.

My high schooler, who always turns down carrot cake saying he "doesn't want veggies in his dessert," changed his mind after one bite of this version. There's just something about that honeybun flavor mixed with the surprise cheesecake that wins over even the biggest carrot cake haters.

Tasty Companions

This rich cake works great with a basic cup of coffee or tea to cut the sweetness. At dinner parties, try adding a tiny scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side for that hot-cold wow factor. During autumn get-togethers, I match it with warm spiced cider for a seasonal feel. My hubby likes his with sweet wine, but I prefer mine with strong black coffee to balance out the sweetness.

Fun Twists

You can throw in some well-drained crushed pineapple to the carrot mix for a beachy vibe. Switch pecans for walnuts or toss in some raisins if that's your thing. For looks, try making patterns on top with chopped nuts, toasted coconut flakes, or just a light sprinkle of cinnamon. Last Easter, I added a teaspoon of orange zest to the mix, which really brightened everything up and worked great with all the spices.

Pin it

I've baked this honeybun carrot cake for everything from Easter lunches to birthday parties, and it always gets huge praise. There's something special about mixing spicy carrot cake, smooth cheesecake filling, and that cinnamon-loaded frosting that makes people smile with their first bite. My little girl has already asked for it at her next birthday party, which tells me it's a real winner. Sometimes the best treats come from mixing old favorites in new and surprising ways.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I prepare this cake ahead of time?

Totally! Make the cake layers a day before and chill them wrapped tightly. You can also frost the whole cake a couple of days in advance and refrigerate. Sitting in the fridge only enhances the flavors.

→ What’s the best way to store leftovers?

Because of the cream cheese frosting and filling, pop leftovers into the fridge. Use an airtight container or cover tightly to keep it from drying out. It stays fresh for up to 5 days. Let it sit out for 20 minutes before serving!

→ Is freezing this cake an option?

Yes, it freezes wonderfully! Wrap slices or the whole cake tightly after freezing solid on a tray. Use foil and plastic wrap or put them in airtight containers. Freeze for up to 3 months and defrost overnight in the fridge.

→ How small should I grate the carrots?

Use the medium side of a box grater or a food processor for best results. You want them small but not mushy. Skip pre-shredded carrots—it’s better to use fresh ones for proper cake moisture.

→ Can I mix in extras to the batter?

Go for it! Pecans, raisins, coconut, or drained crushed pineapple all work. If using pineapple, cut the sour cream in the recipe to ¼ cup to keep the texture balanced. Add spices like ginger or cloves for a more intense flavor!