Cheesecake Filled Cookies

I found this Reese's cheesecake cookie idea during a holiday swap last year. The mix of browned butter, triple chocolate chips, and that hidden cheesecake middle makes them way better than regular cookies. They've become my go-to treat when I need to wow a crowd.

My next-door neighbor's kid dropped by while these were cooling, and just the smell made him hang around. He took one bite, shut his eyes briefly, then asked if I'd show his mother the recipe. The treats that need extra work often get the best reactions.

Premium Ingredients

• Brown butter: Spending time to brown your butter gives these cookies a toasty, sweet flavor you can't get any other way
• Room temperature cream cheese: Makes sure your filling comes out perfectly smooth
• Mix of chocolate chips: Using three different kinds creates better taste and looks more interesting
• Mini Reese's: Their tiny size works perfectly in the dough and adds peanut butter goodness throughout
• Room temperature eggs: Absolutely needed for mixing properly with the butter

Save

Baking Process

Cheesecake Filling

You've got to mix the filling until it's totally smooth - any bumps now will stay after baking. Your cream cheese must be soft and warm; cold cream cheese will always stay lumpy. Those tiny frozen dollops might seem fussy but they're what makes these cookies stand out. I've learned that freezing them on a small cookie sheet works better than using parchment. Freeze them completely solid - if they're soft in the middle, they'll melt too fast while baking and you'll lose that special cheesecake center.

Butter Browning

This part needs your complete focus - look for the change when butter turns from yellow to golden with tiny brown specks at the bottom. The smell shifts from buttery to nutty when it's done. Those brown bits pack tons of flavor - grab them all when you pour it out. I've burnt butter too many times because I got distracted. Now I keep the heat low-medium and stay right by the stove during this key step. That nutty flavor is what makes these cookies different from basic chocolate chip ones.

Cooling Time

Let your browned butter cool until it's warm but not hot. If it's too hot when eggs go in, you'll cook the eggs in your dough - definitely not what we want! I use this cooling time to get everything else ready. The butter should feel warm when added to sugars - this makes a slight caramel taste as they mix together.

Dough Care

Stir this dough lightly just until mixed. Too much mixing makes cookies tough instead of soft. I use a wooden spoon for adding dry ingredients rather than my mixer for better control. The dough comes out a bit thicker than normal cookie dough from the browned butter, but stays soft enough to scoop. When you add chips and Reese's, fold just a few times to spread them out without working the dough too much.

Putting Together

Pressing each dough ball flat and wrapping it around frozen filling takes practice but pays off. Check that there aren't any cracks where filling might leak during baking. I slightly dampen my fingers so dough doesn't stick to them. Work fast - you don't want filling to start thawing before going into the oven.

Baking Details

Keep a close eye on these cookies - they can go from perfect to overdone really fast. They should be golden on bottom but still look slightly soft on top when you take them out. They'll finish cooking as they cool. I start checking at 8 minutes, though 10 usually works in my oven. Don't bake them longer or you'll miss that perfect balance between crispy edge and chewy middle.

My partner usually skips dessert saying he "doesn't like sweet stuff," but he ate three of these in one go and wants them instead of cake for his birthday. Something about the mix of browned butter, triple chocolate, and that soft cheesecake middle makes a snack nobody can turn down.

Tasty Combinations

Enjoy these cookies while they're still warm with a big glass of cold milk. At dessert parties, they go great with coffee or hot cocoa for a comfy combo. During holiday seasons, I put them out with other cookies for options, though these always vanish first. My kids go crazy for them after school with hot chocolate when it's cold outside.

Taste Twists

Add a spoonful of peanut butter to your cheesecake filling for extra nutty flavor. Switch out mini Reese's for cut-up peanut butter cups or Reese's Pieces for a different look and feel. Mix in a teaspoon of espresso powder to boost the chocolate taste without making them taste like coffee. Last Christmas, I tried adding a bit of cinnamon to the dough, which brought a nice warmth that worked really well with all the other flavors.

Save

I've brought these Reese's cheesecake cookies to school fundraisers and fancy dinners, and they always get people talking. There's something special about how the browned butter adds richness, the cheesecake center brings creaminess, and the three chocolates create different flavors in each bite. My kid's friends now ask for them whenever they visit, which tells me they're truly a hit. The recipes that need extra steps often become the ones people remember most.

Recipe FAQs

→ Why should I freeze the cheesecake filling?

Cold cheesecake filling is easier to handle. If it’s too soft, it gets messy fast. Freezing keeps it solid, so wrapping it in dough is simpler, and it stays center when baking.

→ Can I make the cookies smaller?

Totally. Just use about a teaspoon of cheesecake filling for each and shorten baking by 1-2 minutes to avoid overbaking.

→ What if mini Reese’s aren’t available?

Swap for chopped regular Reese’s, Reese’s Pieces, or mix chocolate chips and peanut butter chips for a similar vibe.

→ Why shouldn’t I chill the dough?

Cold brown butter hardens the dough too much, making it tough to work with. Room-temp dough makes it easier to shape and bake just right.

→ How can I tell they’re baked?

Pull them out when the edges are golden but the middle’s slightly soft. They’ll firm up as they cool on the tray.