Colorful Easter Cake

I found this Easter poke cake by accident last year when I needed something fun but quick for our family get-together. The mix of swirly, colorful cake with smooth pudding and light whipped cream makes an amazing treat that looks fancy but isn't hard to make. It's now what we look forward to each Easter, and we enjoy making it just as much as eating it.

When my brother's wife watched me whip this up last Easter, she couldn't believe how easy it was and grabbed the recipe right away. She thought I'd spent hours in the kitchen. It's funny how the easiest things often wow people the most, especially when they look this pretty.

Basic Components

• White cake mix - Works as your starting point for adding those lovely spring colors
• Greek yogurt - This makes your cake super soft and keeps it from drying out
• Gel food coloring - Gives brighter colors without making your batter too thin
• Instant pudding - Fills all those little holes with creamy sweetness
• Fresh whipped cream - Adds that cloud-like layer on top that finishes everything off

Pin it

Sweet Assembly

Mix Preparation

Using Greek yogurt in your cake mix makes it way softer than just following the box. I mix it for two full minutes to get lots of air in there so it rises nicely. When I split the batter, I grab a measuring cup to make sure each bowl gets the same amount for even coloring. Don't skip the gel food coloring - it's much better than the liquid kind that thins out your batter. I always start with tiny dabs of color and add more until I get those soft Easter shades I want.

Swirl Method

For that pretty marble look, just drop spoonfuls of each color randomly in the pan. Don't try to make a perfect pattern. Make sure the different colors touch and overlap. Then just run a knife through very gently. The first time I tried this, I swirled too much and ended up with a weird brownish cake. Now I just do a few quick figure-eights and stop. Every cake turns out different, which makes it special.

Making Holes

I grab a wooden spoon handle to poke holes all over the cake. I keep them about an inch apart and make sure to get right to the edges too. I twist the handle slightly to make the holes a bit wider without ripping the cake. I go about two-thirds down so there's still some solid cake at the bottom but plenty of room for pudding on top. The holes might seem huge at first, but they'll look perfect once filled with pudding.

Filling Process

You've got to move fast after mixing your pudding because it sets up pretty quick. I pour it right away, getting it into the holes first before spreading what's left across the top. I use a soft spatula to push pudding into the holes gently. Then it needs to chill so the pudding can set up and sink into the cake. This creates that amazing texture that's not quite cake and not quite pudding. Sometimes I add a tiny bit of the same food coloring to the pudding too.

Topping Tips

You want to beat the cream until it stands up in stiff peaks so it won't slide off the cake but stays fluffy. I always chill my bowl and beaters in the freezer first for the best results. The sugar melts in as you beat it, making it just sweet enough to balance the cake below. I usually add a little vanilla to the cream too. I spread it all the way to the sides to help lock in moisture.

Decoration Ideas

The coconut on top isn't just pretty - it tastes amazing and gives you that Easter basket feel. I usually color some of the coconut with a drop of green food coloring to look more like grass. Then I add Easter sprinkles and those tiny chocolate eggs in little clusters rather than scattering them everywhere. This makes it look like I spent ages decorating when it only took minutes.

Last Easter, my fussy niece helped me put chocolate eggs on top of this cake. She took her time placing each one just right. When everyone sat down to eat, she made sure to point out which part she'd decorated. Sometimes these little kitchen moments with kids turn into the best holiday memories.

Tasty Companions

This bright dessert goes great with a hot cup of coffee or tea in the afternoon. It can be the star of your Easter dessert table with some fresh fruits on the side. Some folks like it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream for an extra treat. My little ones always want it with big glasses of cold milk for dunking.

Mix It Up

You can switch things around by using chocolate cake with chocolate pudding if you've got chocolate fans at home. Or try swapping vanilla pudding for lemon or coconut flavors. Adding fresh strawberries or blueberries between the pudding and cream layers tastes amazing too. Last year I played around with different flavors in the whipped cream - adding a bit of almond extract was really good with the vanilla pudding.

Pin it

I've taken this Easter poke cake to family dinners, church gatherings, and school events, and it always gets people talking. Something about those rainbow swirls mixed with creamy layers just makes everyone happy. My little girl now helps me make it each spring, dropping in colorful batter and placing decorations on top. We're building a sweet tradition I hope she'll share with her own kids someday. The best recipes aren't just about good food - they're about coming together to create something special that everyone can enjoy.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Is there another cake mix option?

Totally! Vanilla or yellow cake mix works nicely. Just note that darker mixes won't let the pastel shades pop as much.

→ How early can I prep this?

You’ve got 1-2 days. Go for Cool Whip if it's over 12 hours to keep it holding up well.

→ Will liquid food color work?

Sure, but gels give bolder colors without thinning. If you go liquid, you’ll probably need more drops.

→ Why is my cake too wet in spots?

Let it cool down fully before adding pudding. And keep the holes smaller and more spaced out.

→ Can I freeze left-over slices?

Freezing’s tricky—it messes with the texture of whipped cream and pudding when thawed.

→ What other fun toppings could I use?

Pastel M&Ms, Cadbury egg bits, jelly beans, or cute Easter candy all work beautifully.