Save
Ultra-fudgy bars packed with bright, crunchy M&M's hit that sweet spot between chewy chocolate bliss and crisp candy shell. They're a fun chocolate upgrade that'll disappear fast at parties or just on a cozy afternoon.
After a ton of trials, chilling the melted chocolate mix slightly before tossing in eggs made the chewiness pop. Trust me, it's totally worth the extra few minutes.
Unforgettable Ingredients:
- M&M's - Pick your favorite color combo for every occasion; place on top, don't stir into the mix
- Butter, good quality - Go with European styles if you want extra richness
- Brown sugar - Helps with both chew and moisture; either dark or light is fine
- Room-temp eggs - Make all the difference for that crinkly, shiny finish
- Dutch cocoa - Deepens chocolate flavors and gives a darker look; always sift out those clumps
Step-by-Step Directions:
Line your dish and smooth down some parchment. Set the oven while you get going. In a bowl over simmering water, mix your butter, chocolate, and both sugars. Stir as it melts and turns glossy. Keep an eye out so nothing scorches.
It's time to take it off the heat and let it rest for about 10 minutes. If the mix is too hot, eggs might scramble; if it's cold, you'll miss that glassy top.
Add in eggs, one at a time, really whisking after each until it looks super shiny and thick. Stop mixing right after each egg so you don't get airy cake instead.
Blend flour and cocoa after sifting together. Gently fold into your batter just until streaks are nearly gone—if you overdo it, the brownies get tough.
Scoop your batter in, spread flat, and scatter M&M's over the top. Let them sit right on top—don't push them in—so you get that bright finish and the shells stay nice and crisp.
Save
If you want perfect clean slices, let brownies chill all the way before cutting—your squares will come out sharp every single time.
Best Pan Choice:
Stick with a metal 8x8 for the ultimate bite. It heats nicer than glass, so you get those crisp edges and dense middle every time.
Fun Mix-In Options:
After experimenting for years, there are so many fun twists. My kid swears by mixing dark and white chocolate M&M’s for a little extra pop.
Serving and Style:
Brownies are awesome slightly warmed up with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. If you're celebrating, sprinkle some powdered sugar or pour a little chocolate drizzle on before you dig in.
Easy Storage Tips:
Keep them wrapped at room temp for up to five days
Freeze single squares for up to three months
When you want one, just let it thaw on the counter overnight
Nailing That Texture:
The secret for keeping 'em perfectly gooey? Let them cool all the way in the pan, then give them one extra hour of rest before slicing in.
Gifting Ideas:
They make super cute gifts—layer your bars between parchment in a fun tin. Pop in a note: “Microwave for 10 seconds to make them taste like fresh out the oven.”
Chef's Last Few Hints:
Stick a skewer two inches from the side to test if they're baked through
Want more chocolate flavor? Add a pinch of espresso powder
Toss a handful of extra M&M's on after baking as a colorful topper
Save
After trial after trial, these bars make life easy but feel indulgent. The blend of rich chocolate and those cheerful M&M’s hits all the right notes—fancy and nostalgic at once.
How to Serve:
Dress them up by warming and topping with whipped cream and some fresh fruit. For a party, slice them into smaller, two-bite pieces everybody can grab and go.
Wrap-Up Hints:
Let everything warm up to room temp first
Offset spatulas help get those smooth tops
Store in a single layer to keep your M&M's looking sharp
These bars are the best of both worlds—super easy to toss together at home, but always look gorgeous when you serve them. They're my trusty pick from bake sales to birthday blowouts.
Party-Ready Ideas:
Bars are easy to change up for every event—not just holidays.
Pinks and blues fit a baby shower
School colors for team wins
Go for shiny metallic candies for wedding favors too
Fixing Common Problems:
Edges too chewy? Take a few minutes off baking time
Middle too soft? Wait till they've cooled before slicing
Candy shells cracked? Add M&M's in the last few baking minutes
Pro Baking Tricks:
Parchment hanging over the sides makes it a breeze to lift brownies out
Poke with a toothpick two inches from the side to check for doneness
For the neatest slices, cool entirely before cutting
Science Behind Fudgy Goodness:
The reason they're so gooey? Lots of butter and not too much flour. More fat and less flour gives you that rich, dense bite.
Chef’s Last Wisdom:
Don't skip the full cooling stage—it really makes a difference
Halfway through baking, spin the pan for even doneness
Slice with a warm, clean knife for those straight lines
I’ve been baking these for years and they always turn out picture-perfect—just the right balance of cozy and fancy. Everyone requests them for parties because they're reliable and always impress.
To me, these brownies are everything great about homemade treats—totally doable for newbies, but pretty enough for special events. Need a holiday fix or chocolate pick-me-up? These M&M squares always hit the spot.