Granny Cake Dessert

Baked-from-scratch Granny Cake brings all that cozy, old-school homemade goodness. Each bite is crazy moist, bursting with juicy pineapple, then gets a top layer of pecans and buttery brown sugar, before getting drenched in sweet icing that soaks deep into every corner. This classic sweet gives major nostalgia—think get-togethers, holidays, and memories that stick with you. Seriously, it’s sweet, shiny, tender, and has all those vibes that make you want another bite before you’ve finished the first one.

I stumbled on this old dessert in my granny’s notebook, splashed with vanilla spots and scribbled reminders. First time I made it for my folks, the whole house smelled like we’d gone back in time. What gets me every time is that warm icing—when it seeps in and makes chewy, sweet little pockets under the crackly pecan top.

Dreamy Cake Layers

• Pecans: Throw in some crunch and balance all that sweetness
• Brown sugar: Melts during baking, giving a gooey, caramel-like crust up top
• Crushed pineapples: The secret for ultra-juicy, lightly tropical cake
• Eggs: Holds everything together and gives a little richness
• Salt: Makes all the other flavors pop, keeps things from being too sweet
• Baking soda: Adds lift and fluff, reacting with the pineapple juice
• All-purpose flour: The cake’s backbone—soaks up juice and turns it into crumb
• White sugar: Gives just-right sweetness and softness

Topping Must-Haves

• Vanilla extract: Rounds out the flavors with a cozy smell
• Unsalted butter: Makes the topping creamy and full-flavored
• White sugar: Adds in some sweetness for that slick finish
• Evaporated milk: Brings rich cream flavor without making things runny

Step-by-Step Fun

Starting Off:

Heat oven to 350°F and grease a big 9×13 baking pan. Make sure to get into the edges so it’ll all come out easy.

Making Your Batter:

Get your sugar, flour, baking soda, and salt into a big bowl and whisk them together. Tip in the canned pineapple with juice and crack in the eggs. Use a spatula to gently mix—stop when it’s mostly smooth but with a few pineapple chunks peeking through. Batter will be fairly thick.

Putting it Together:

Scrape batter into the waiting pan, smoothing it out so it reaches the corners. Shower the top with your pecans, then get a layer of brown sugar over the whole pan. These melt and bake into a crunchy top and caramel goo.

Whipping Up Icing:

While the cake’s baking, let’s fix the icing. In a saucepan, combine butter, sugar, and evaporated milk—stir over medium heat until the butter’s melted and everything’s smooth. Let it bubble just a bit till it thickens a touch, then take it off and add vanilla. The icing should pour easily but still coat the spoon.

The Grand Finale:

Once a toothpick slides out mostly clean (with soft crumbs), grab the cake from the oven. Poke it everywhere using a skewer or toothpick. Pour on your hot icing so it seeps into every hole and around the toasted pecans. Leave everything in the pan to cool down and let that icing work its magic.

Save

My grandma swore by only using canned pineapple. She said it baked up sweeter and more reliable every time. Around here, we always serve this dessert a little warm with a cup of coffee after Sunday lunch. That sweet cake plus strong coffee? Pure memory on a plate.

Perfect Matches

This simple beauty goes best with sides that don’t overpower. Try a hunk with some soft whipped cream—just a hint of sugar and real vanilla. For big celebrations, give each slice a quick zap to warm, then drop on a scoop of butter pecan ice cream. Want to finish it off properly? Grab a mug of black coffee or hot tea—the combo cuts the sweet and just works.

Twist It Up

Switch things around with little tweaks through the year. No pecans? Toasted walnuts or macadamias taste great. Stir in half a teaspoon of cinnamon for cozy vibes that go awesome with pineapple. Or go tropical by swapping coconut milk for the topping and dropping toasted coconut on the finish.

Keeping it Fresh

Wrap your cake up tight and leave it out on the counter for up to three days—actually gets even better on day two. Fridge it in something airtight if you’re going longer (up to a week). When it’s time to serve, microwave a piece for twenty seconds so it tastes brand new and lets the flavors shine.

These days, folks expect me to bring this dessert to every big family meal. As soon as it hits the table, we wind up swapping stories about favorite foods and family traditions. What really makes it special? Even though the ingredients are nothing fancy, it turns out tasting like the best kind of comfort food. When you’re tired of over-the-top desserts, serving this is a reminder that sometimes simple is the best kind of special.

Save

Recipe FAQs

→ Can fresh pineapple replace canned?

Canned pineapple works best for sweetness and moisture, but you can use fresh pineapple if you crush it and add about 1/4 cup pineapple juice or water.

→ How should I store leftover cake?

Keep it covered at room temperature for up to 3 days, or refrigerate for a week. The pineapple and glaze help it stay moist.

→ Can pecans be swapped for another nut?

Definitely! Walnuts are a great alternative, or try sliced almonds. You can also skip the nuts if you prefer.

→ Why is this called Granny Cake?

It got the name because it’s an old-school recipe that grandmas loved to make. The simple ingredients and comforting flavor bring back memories for many.

→ Is it okay to make this cake ahead?

Yes! It actually tastes better the next day as the flavors meld together. Just cover it well once it cools.