Save
I stumbled on these Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookies during a midnight baking session. Missing the classic sandwiches my mom used to make, I wondered if I could pack those same flavors into a cookie. After tons of kitchen experiments, I nailed it - they're chewy, soft and bring back all those childhood feels.
Sweet Cookie Bliss
The aroma that fills my kitchen when I bake these is unbeatable - warm nutty peanut butter mixing with sweet fruity jam. Watching them come out of the oven with their golden edges and perfectly set jam centers just makes me smile. And guess what? You probably already have everything you need to make them.
What You'll Need
- All-Purpose Flour: This forms the base of our cookie creation.
- Peanut Butter: I always go for the smooth variety.
- Both Sugars: White for crispness, brown for softness.
- Your Favorite Jam: I love strawberry but pick whatever makes you happy.
- Fresh Egg: Make sure it's not cold from the fridge for best results.
- Leaveners: These give our cookies the perfect rise and texture.
Save
Making It Your Own
For friends who can't eat peanuts, I sometimes use almond butter instead. Got gluten issues? Just swap in your favorite one-to-one gluten-free flour mix. As for the jam, anything goes. My children can't get enough of grape, but I'm all about raspberry.
Let's Make Magic
Get going by combining the dry stuff first - they're what give your cookies structure. Next, beat your butter with sugars until they look pale and fluffy. Don't rush this part, it's key for amazing texture. When you mix in the peanut butter, you'll see the dough transform right before your eyes.
Time to Shape
I love rolling these little guys in sugar before they go in the oven - they get such a pretty shimmer. I make little dents with my thumb for the jam, but you can use a measuring spoon too. Take your time here - those jam-filled centers are what makes everyone come back for seconds.
Save
The Baking Dance
Watch them closely while they're in the oven - in my kitchen 14 minutes usually does the trick. You want those edges just turning golden with tiny little cracks forming on top. That's your signal they'll have that amazing chewy bite we're going for.
Extra Special Version
Want to really knock someone's socks off? Try my stuffed version. Just freeze small chunks of peanut butter and jam, then wrap cookie dough around them. They bake up with the most incredible melty center you've ever tried.
Keeping Them Fresh
Store these gems in an airtight container and they'll stay soft for days. If they hang around that long - mine always vanish fast! Sometimes I double the batch and freeze half the dough for when cookie cravings hit.
Planning Ahead
This dough actually turns out better after chilling in the fridge. I often mix it up the evening before having friends over for coffee. There's something so welcoming about greeting guests with cookies fresh from the oven.
My Best Tips
Go easy on the mixing - too much and your cookies won't be tender. Let your ingredients sit out before you start. And please don't skimp on the jam quality - it really shows in the final taste.
Fun Twists
- Chocolate Lover's Dream: Try adding some melted chocolate on top for extra decadence.
- Allergy Friendly: Swap in Sunbutter to make them safe for school lunches.
- Jam Adventures: Give apricot a try for a surprisingly tasty change.
Serving Joy
Grab some cold milk or brew a pot of coffee - these treats deserve good company. I've brought them to everything from kids' snack time to fancy dinner gatherings. They just bring smiles all around.
Questions I Get Asked
- Crunchy PB? You can use it but your cookies will have more bits in them.
- Best Jam? I find seedless works nicest but go with what you enjoy.
- Freezing? The unbaked dough freezes better than finished cookies but both work fine.
Cookie Love
These PB&J cookies have become my go-to treat, the one everyone asks for at gatherings and family always expects. They're more than just dessert - they're little bites of happiness that connect us to sweet childhood memories while making new ones.
Save
Wrap-Up
These soft cookies mix peanut butter flavor with sweet strawberry jam in the center. Finished with a peanut butter drizzle and nut topping, they’re simple, tasty, and easy to make.
Recipe FAQs
- → Why is chilling the dough helpful?
Letting it chill for 30-60 minutes stops it from spreading too much while baking. It’s optional but helps with cookie shape.
- → Can I swap the jam flavor?
Yes, you can use any smooth jam like grape, strawberry, or raspberry for a fun change.
- → How do I keep them fresh?
Store in a sealed container at room temperature for 3 days or refrigerate up to a week. They’re tasty cold too!
- → What is the scoot technique?
After baking, use a round cutter to press spread-out edges back into a neat circle before they cool.
- → Can I freeze them?
Yes, freeze the baked cookies for up to 3 months. Thaw them in the fridge and add fresh jam right before serving.