Pin it
These peanut butter chocolate chip cookie cups were born from a desire to create something special for a neighborhood holiday exchange. By baking the dough in muffin tins, you get perfectly shaped treats with a tender center and crisp edges. While they look sophisticated, they're actually simpler to make than traditional drop cookies.
The first time I served these still warm from the oven, the room fell silent as everyone savored their first bite. They've since become a most-requested treat, winning over even the pickiest dessert critics. The combination of classic flavors in this unique form creates something truly special.
Key Ingredients
- Peanut butter: Choose smooth or crunchy based on texture preference
- Brown sugar: Provides moisture and rich caramel notes
- Butter: Room temperature for proper creaming
- Chocolate chips: A blend of milk and semi-sweet adds depth
- Pure vanilla: Enhances both peanut butter and chocolate flavors
Pin it
Preparation Method
- Pan Preparation
- A light coating of cooking spray works best for easy release. While paper liners are convenient, direct contact with the tin creates the ideal crispy edge texture. The metal surface is key for achieving that perfect contrast between center and edge.
- Butter Mixture
- Take time to properly cream the butter and sugar until light and fluffy, about 2-3 minutes. The butter should be soft enough to leave an impression when pressed but not melted. This step creates the foundation for the perfect texture.
- Adding Peanut Butter
- Thoroughly incorporate the peanut butter into the butter-sugar mixture before adding eggs. Traditional peanut butter brands provide the most consistent results. If using natural peanut butter, ensure it's well-mixed before measuring.
- Flour Incorporation
- Add dry ingredients gradually in three additions, mixing just until combined. Overmixing leads to tough cookies. Some small flour lumps are fine and will bake out. Mix on low speed just until flour disappears.
- Filling Muffin Tins
- Fill cups 3/4 full using a cookie scoop for consistency. Create a small indent in each dough ball. Reserve some chocolate chips for topping to ensure chocolate in every bite.
- Baking Guidelines
- Watch carefully as baking time is crucial. Edges should be golden while centers remain slightly soft. Start checking at 10 minutes. Test edges with a toothpick - a few moist crumbs are ideal.
The appeal of these cookie cups extends beyond typical dessert lovers. The balanced flavor combination and unique texture create an irresistible treat that consistently earns praise and recipe requests.
Serving Suggestions
Serve slightly warm with vanilla ice cream for an elevated dessert. They pair beautifully with coffee or hot chocolate for afternoon treats. During holidays, they stand out on cookie platters and transport well for gatherings. They're sturdy enough for lunchboxes while being special enough for celebrations.
Recipe Variations
Add mini peanut butter cups to the centers while warm. Incorporate chopped peanuts for extra crunch. Drizzle with melted chocolate and sea salt after cooling. A teaspoon of cinnamon in the dry ingredients adds wonderful warmth to the classic flavors.
Pin it
From casual snacks to special occasions, these peanut butter chocolate chip cookie cups consistently impress. The familiar flavors combined in this unique form create something memorable yet approachable. They've become a favorite pass-along recipe, perfect for both novice and experienced bakers.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I bake these with natural peanut butter?
- Yep, but keep in mind they might turn out textured a little differently. Regular creamy or chunky peanut butter works best if you're after consistent results. If you're going with natural, stir it super well to get rid of any extra oil.
- → How can I tell if the cookie cups are done baking?
- They're ready when the edges have a light golden touch and the centers are still a little soft. Be careful not to bake them too long if you want that chewy bite! They'll firm up a bit as they cool in the tin.
- → Can these cookie cups be made ahead?
- For sure! Keep them sealed in an airtight container and they'll stay fresh at room temperature for about 5 days. Or pop them in the freezer for up to 3 months—just thaw or warm them up before serving.
- → What can replace chocolate chips in this recipe?
- You could swap them with peanut butter chips, chunks of candy like peanut butter cups, or white chocolate morsels. Mix a few of these for a fun twist!
- → Can I make these smaller with a mini tin?
- Absolutely! Use a mini muffin pan and bake them for 8-10 minutes instead. You'll end up with 24-30 mini cookie cups, which are ideal for snacking or party trays.