Soft Peanut Butter Blondies

One night, my daughter let me know she needed treats for a Valentine's party the very next day. What started out as a bit of a kitchen scramble ended with my most popular baked good. Everybody loves these—soft in the center, crisp on the edges, with creamy peanut butter and happy splashes of M&Ms. They're like a peanut butter cookie that got all dressed up for Valentine's Day.

So here’s the thing: I once brought these to my kid’s basketball party. Those usually-unimpressed teens kept sneaking over, nabbing seconds and thirds. By the time we got home, a few moms had already texted me asking for the secret. That’s when I realized these bars hit the spot every time.

Irresistible Ingredients

• Butter, melted: Make sure it’s just melted, not sizzling hot–adds rich flavor
• Standard peanut butter: Don’t swap for natural; otherwise you’ll get greasy bars
• Brown sugar (light): Makes the blondies chewy and sweet, almost like caramel
• Eggs: Keeps everything together just right
• Vanilla (real): Really wakes up every other flavor
• Flour, all-purpose: Gives body so they hold together
• Pink and red M&Ms: Little pops of color and crunch in every piece

Save

Blondie Magic

Start off right:

Melt your butter (not too hot), otherwise you might end up with scrambled eggs

Mix in:

Stir in the peanut butter until it feels creamy and smooth

Sugar time:

Dump in the brown sugar and stir until it all blends and shines

Get glossy:

Add the eggs and vanilla, then mix until it looks thick and shiny

Gently fold:

Stir in the flour real gentle—think of it like tucking in a kid at bedtime

M&Ms go in:

Mix a bunch of M&Ms right in the batter for extra fun

Spread it out:

Pat the dough gently into your pan

Toss more on:

Scatter even more M&Ms over the top—cause you can never have too many

Watch them bake:

Peek through the oven window for that golden top

Toothpick test:

Poke one in—the bars are done when you see a few moist crumbs

Let them set:

Seriously, let them cool off no matter how hard that is

Slice up:

Cut into bars, then try to save some for later!

Sweet Kitchen Wisdom

After making these so many times, take it from me—let them chill! If you sneak a bite too soon, they’ll fall apart. Still tasty, but super messy. I usually bake them the day before I need them. The texture is actually better the next day and the M&Ms keep their crunch. That first piece when they’re totally cool? Pure happiness.

Switch It Up

I’ve tinkered with this so many times. For Christmas, I switch to red and green M&Ms and my kitchen looks like the North Pole. If you swirl Nutella on top before baking, my kids lose their minds. Once I went super fancy and browned the butter first—the flavor got so deep and nutty. Still, I always come back to the classic.

Blondie Longevity

Here’s what works for keeping them fresh—they stay soft and chewy all week if you pop them into an airtight container. I use my grandma’s old cookie tin with wax paper between layers. Though honestly, they never last long. To save them longer, wrap each bar and stash 'em in the freezer. My daughter calls these 'emergency happiness bars.' She loves digging one out after a rough school day.

Share The Sweetness

I bring these bars to pretty much every event now. I wrap them up in gift boxes lined with parchment for teacher thank-yous. Last year, I baked triple batches for my kids’ classrooms—parents still mention them! There’s just something about homemade sweets that the store ones can’t touch.

Save

Baker’s Little Tricks

• Peek at them near the end so they don’t overbake
• Let the bars cool in their pan on a cooling rack—the air flow really matters
• Use a plastic knife when slicing for those flawless squares

These blondies are more than something I bake—they're a piece of our family. There for every birthday, rough Monday, or chill Sunday afternoon. Making them always reminds me: the best joys are the simple ones, baked with a little bit of love.

Recipe FAQs

→ Why shouldn’t I use natural peanut butter?

Natural peanut butter can separate and turn oily, which messes with the texture. Stick to brands like Jif or Skippy instead.

→ Can I add different kinds of M&Ms?

Absolutely! Use peanut, dark chocolate, or seasonal M&Ms, but keep the amount the same.

→ How can I tell when the blondies are done?

Stick a toothpick in the center. If it comes out clean with just a few crumbs, it’s ready. Wet batter means it needs more time.

→ Can these blondies be frozen?

Yes, wrap them tightly in an airtight container, and they’ll stay good for up to four months.

→ Why should I wait an hour before cutting them?

Cooling lets the blondies firm up, making it easier to slice them neatly.