Pin it
This beefed-up twist on traditional broccoli cheddar soup brings all the comfort you crave while keeping your nutrition goals intact. The unexpected champion? Cottage cheese creates amazing smoothness and bumps the protein to a whopping 20g per serving, ditching the need for heavy cream. Every bite blends soft broccoli chunks with tangy cheddar in a smooth, rich broth that'll make you want more.
When I first whipped this soup up for my crew, they had no clue cottage cheese was working its magic inside. My teenage kid, who typically runs from anything labeled "healthier version," grabbed seconds and asked if we could put it on our normal dinner lineup.
Key Components
- Fresh broccoli: Go for firm, deep green clusters with no yellow spots. Don't toss those stems - they add tons of flavor
- Sharp cheddar: Treat yourself to quality block cheese and shred it at home. The bagged stuff contains coatings that mess with how it melts
- Cottage cheese: This sneaky superstar adds protein and silkiness. Both regular and reduced-fat work great
- Smoked paprika: Just a pinch brings mysterious depth that'll get folks wondering what your trick is
- Quality vegetable broth: This forms your soup's foundation. I like making mine, but a premium store option is fine too
Detailed Step-by-Step Instructions
Kick Things Off
Let butter melt in a Dutch oven over medium flame. Toss in chopped onions and cook till they turn clear and smell good, roughly 4-5 minutes. Mix in crushed garlic and give it another minute till that lovely smell fills your kitchen.
Pin it
Fix The Base
Dust flour over your veggies and keep stirring for about 2 minutes. This gets rid of that raw flour taste. Now add smoked paprika - it wakes up in the warmth and spreads its mild smokiness throughout.
Grow Your Soup
Slowly pour in broth while whisking nonstop to avoid clumps. Drop in chopped broccoli pieces, let it bubble gently, and cook till broccoli softens but stays green - around 8-10 minutes. You want it tender enough to eat but not mushy.
Add Smoothness
This is where things get good. Whip your cottage cheese till smooth, then mix it into the soup with milk. Let everything warm up, then gradually stir in grated cheddar until it's all melted and silky.
For crazy weeknights, I often cut up broccoli and onions ahead of time. There's nothing better than coming home knowing dinner is partly done. The aroma of onions and garlic cooking always draws my family into the kitchen.
Fancy Broccoli Touches
I enjoy switching up toppings to give each serving something special. Sometimes I'll throw on:
- More oven-roasted broccoli bits for extra crunch
- A handful of crunchy bacon pieces
- Homemade chunky bread cubes
- A few shakes of hot sauce for those who like heat
Pin it
Prep Ahead Suggestions
This soup gets thicker as it rests. When warming it up again, add a splash of warm milk if it's too thick. While many creamy soups turn grainy when reheated, the cottage cheese in this recipe helps keep everything smooth.
This soup has become my favorite after-gym dinner. The protein aids muscle repair while still feeling like a warm hug in a bowl. It shows that good-for-you food doesn't need to taste like you're giving something up - sometimes it's actually tastier than the classic version.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why do you blend cottage cheese?
- Blending smooths it out, giving a creamy texture and hiding the curds while keeping it protein-rich.
- → Will frozen broccoli work?
- Definitely. No need to thaw, just cook it a bit longer by adding a minute.
- → How can I stop curdling?
- Keep the heat low when adding dairy and stir consistently to prevent any separation.
- → Is this gluten-free?
- It can be! Just swap regular flour with gluten-free flour of your choice.
- → How should I store it?
- Keep it in a sealed container in the fridge for up to four days. Warm it gently to avoid splitting.