Pin it
This bold, multipurpose Cowboy Butter turns everyday butter into a taste-loaded spread that'll turn any meal into something to remember. Once I tried it, I started stashing a roll in my fridge on the regular—you just can't get enough.
Just last week, I brought this out at a dinner and everyone was fighting to grab the last swipe for their steak. The way the herbs mix with the little heat from cayenne always wins people over.
Tasty Ingredients Rundown
- Spices: That combo of cayenne and chili flakes is just the right warmth
- Garlic: Use freshly minced, it's a world apart from the pre-chopped tub
- Dijon Mustard: Brings a bit of zing but stays subtle—grainy is especially great
- Fresh Herbs: Use whatever's freshest—backyard herbs if you've got 'em make this sing
- Butter: Let it soften on the counter so it blends perfectly—don't even try with cold butter
Pin it
Let's Jump In
- For Dipping:
- Pop into the microwave in short bursts, stirring in between, and don't let it get too hot
- Chilling Out:
- Let it hang out in the fridge until firm—at least a couple hours, though overnight is even better
- Get Shaping:
- Lay some plastic wrap out, pile the butter on, and roll it up tight—twist those ends good
- Put Everything Together:
- Toss all your goodies in one bowl and stir, taste, and tweak the flavors til you're happy
- Get Your Stuff Ready:
- Let that butter soften on its own, run your knife through those herbs, and mince your fresh garlic as chunky or fine as you like
Here's why this butter is always in my fridge. One Sunday while grilling steaks, I added a few slices on top. Now every time my grandson visits, he begs for what he calls "cowboy steak." It's wild how such a simple thing turns into a family favorite.
Ways I Use It
After trying it out basically everywhere, I've found this butter is a game changer. A pat tossed on roast veggies, spread on piping hot cornbread, or swirled into pasta is unbeatable. Last Thanksgiving, I snuck some under the turkey skin—and wow, I swear it made the bird legendary!
Keep It Fresh
To keep things simple, I break the butter into smaller bits before I stick it in the freezer. That way, it's easy to grab just what I need. Little paper cups work like a charm—just toss them all in a bag and pop it in the freezer.
Pin it
Make It Yours
I love swapping in herbs depending on what’s out back. Rosemary gives it a cozy winter vibe, basil is perfect come summer. My daughter loves loading up with extra garlic—she jokes it's her secret to avoiding vampires!
Top Pairings
- Perfect slathered on grilled corn for sunny days
- Drizzle it over baked potatoes for instant comfort
- Basic bread with this—total upgrade
- Throw some on grilled shrimp—trust me, it's something else
This isn't just a butter around here—it's a little tradition. Whether I'm jazzing up basic chicken or trying to wow the crowd at a BBQ, it always takes things up a notch. The real win? It's so easy that even my brother-in-law (who can't cook to save his life!) has mastered it. Just don’t tell him I said so!