Creamy Avgolemono Soup

In my half-Greek family, Sundays were always filled with the zingy, citrusy smell of avgolemono soup floating through the house. This isn't your regular chicken soup – it's what happens when basic broth gets a Mediterranean makeover and turns into something totally different. The real trick comes from mixing eggs and lemon together, which changes plain broth into something smooth, tangy and so comforting. While my grandma would cook this all day long, I've come up with a quick version that gives you all those authentic tastes in just about 30 minutes. It's now my favorite comfort food when it's cold outside or when somebody's feeling sick.

During a really cold spell last winter, I cooked a giant batch of this soup and dropped some off for my sick neighbor. She texted me the next day wanting to know how to make it, saying it worked "better than medicine" for helping her sore throat and stuffed nose. There's something about the mix of soothing broth, comfy rice, protein-packed eggs and vitamin-rich lemon that seems to make you feel better almost right away.

Must-Have Ingredients

• Chicken Broth - I grab store-bought low-sodium broth when I'm busy, but homemade will make your soup even tastier. The quality of your broth really matters here.
• Rotisserie Chicken - This handy shortcut saves tons of time without losing flavor. Thigh meat adds more richness, but any part works fine.
• Arborio Rice - Its natural starchiness helps thicken the soup. Plus, those plump, soft grains add wonderful body to every spoonful.
• Fresh Lemons - Don't even think about using bottled juice. You need the bright oils from real lemon zest and juice for that true flavor.
• Eggs - These create that signature smooth texture and richness. Eggs with bright yellow yolks will give your soup a gorgeous golden color.
• Aromatics - Carrots, celery, and green onions work together to create a flavorful base that gives the broth subtle sweetness and depth.
• Fresh Herbs - Tossing in some fresh dill at the end lifts everything up with its unique grassy, licorice-like flavor.
• Bay Leaves - These quiet little leaves do important work in the background, adding complex flavor notes to the broth as it cooks.
• Garlic - Just a bit adds richness without taking over the delicate lemon taste. I smash it rather than chop it to get more flavor out.

Pin it

Soup Steps

Build Your Base

Warm up some olive oil in a Dutch oven or heavy pot over medium heat. Toss in your finely chopped carrots and celery along with sliced green onions (white and light green parts). Let them cook until they're just soft, around 3-4 minutes, giving them a stir now and then. This gentle cooking brings out their natural sweetness without browning. Add your crushed garlic and cook just until you can smell it, about 30 seconds – cooking garlic too long makes it taste bitter.

Create The Broth

Add 8 cups of chicken broth and drop in two bay leaves. Turn up the heat and let it come to a good boil. While you're waiting, rinse your rice with cold water to wash off extra starch. Once the broth is bubbling, add the rice, turn heat down to medium-low, and sprinkle in some kosher salt and fresh black pepper. Let it simmer gently for about 20 minutes, stirring now and then so the rice doesn't stick to the bottom.

Add Protein

When your rice feels tender but still has a tiny bit of firmness, mix in about 2 cups of shredded rotisserie chicken. Let it warm up for around 2 minutes. The chicken will get a bit softer as it sits in the hot broth, which keeps it from getting tough or stringy.

Make Magic Happen

Now comes the key step that turns ordinary chicken soup into avgolemono! In a bowl, beat two large eggs until they're frothy, then slowly mix in ½ cup of fresh lemon juice. Here's the tricky part: while whisking constantly with one hand, slowly pour in two ladles of hot soup broth with your other hand. This gentle warming process heats the eggs without cooking them into scrambled eggs. If you're worried about managing this, ask someone to help pour while you keep whisking.

Final Touch

Pour your warmed egg-lemon mix back into the pot while stirring non-stop, then RIGHT AWAY take it off the heat. Don't let the soup boil after adding the avgolemono mix or it'll separate. The leftover heat will thicken the soup a bit as the eggs cook very gently in the hot liquid. Take out the bay leaves, taste it and add more salt or fresh black pepper if needed.

My Greek grandma always told me the key to perfect avgolemono is "taking your time and using good stuff." She would always taste the soup before serving and often squeeze in extra fresh lemon at the last minute, saying it "brings all the flavors to life." I've learned she was totally right – that final touch of tanginess makes all the difference between good soup and amazing soup.

Serving Ideas

Make your weeknight dinner special by dishing up hot bowls of avgolemono with some warm pita bread and an easy Greek salad loaded with crunchy cucumbers, ripe tomatoes, tasty kalamata olives, and crumbly feta cheese. The cool, crisp salad works perfectly against the warm, smooth soup.

Put together an easy but fancy Mediterranean feast by serving smaller amounts of avgolemono to start, followed by Greek lemon chicken with potatoes and some garlicky cooked greens on the side. My family can't get enough of this combo for Sunday dinners or when friends come over wanting something more interesting than the usual dinner options.

For lunch get-togethers, pour avgolemono into mugs and serve with Mediterranean open-faced sandwiches on crusty bread. This soup-and-sandwich pairing feels familiar but special, and guests can drink their soup while chatting. I've done this for casual women's lunches and everyone always wants to know how to make it.

Tasty Twists

Orzo Option

For a different feel, swap in 1 cup of orzo pasta instead of rice. It cooks faster (about 7-8 minutes) and makes a somewhat lighter soup that still keeps that wonderful silky texture.

Veggie Boost

To make a heartier soup, throw in a handful of fresh spinach or baby kale during the last minute of cooking. The warm soup will soften the greens without overcooking them, adding color, nutrients, and texture.

Herb Variations

While not strictly old-school, adding a handful of fresh chopped dill at the very end brings freshness and works amazingly with the lemon. Mint or parsley are also great for a fresh spin on the classic version.

Storage Solutions

Refrigerator Ready

This soup needs special handling when storing. Let it cool completely before putting it in airtight containers. Keep it in the fridge for up to 3 days, but know that the rice will keep soaking up liquid, making the soup thicker as time passes.

When warming up refrigerated avgolemono, do it slowly over medium-low heat, stirring often to prevent it from breaking apart. Never let it boil! If it's gotten too thick overnight, add a splash of chicken broth or warm water to thin it out.

For meal planning, think about keeping the cooked soup base (before adding the egg-lemon mix) and the shredded chicken separate. When you're ready to eat, heat up the soup base, add the chicken to warm it, then make and mix in fresh avgolemono. This gives you that just-made creaminess and flavor even several days later.

Freezer Friendly

Unlike many soups with cream, avgolemono freezes pretty well. Put completely cooled soup into freezer containers, leaving about an inch of space at the top for expansion. Freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw in the fridge overnight before warming gently on the stove, stirring often.

Pin it

Chef Tips

Rice Prep

Letting the rice soak in cold water for 15-20 minutes before adding it to your soup helps it cook more evenly and keeps it from getting too starchy or clumpy.

Lemon Technique

Push whole lemons firmly on the counter with your palm before juicing to break down the insides and get more juice with less work.

Temperature Test

If you're scared about warming the eggs properly, try this trick: after mixing eggs and lemon, dip a spoon in the hot broth, then let a drop fall onto the egg mixture. If it doesn't instantly cook, your broth is the right temperature.

One of my favorite memories is showing my daughter how to make this soup when she was in high school. She was worried about the egg warming step but really wanted to get it right. When she tasted her finished soup for the first time, her eyes got big and she said, "It tastes just like Yiayia's!" There's something really special about sharing these family recipes – they carry not just flavors but family stories in every spoonful. Now she makes it in her college apartment and sends me proud pictures of her creamy, lemony creation.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What’s the purpose of tempering eggs in this soup?

By gradually adding hot broth to the egg-lemon mix while whisking, you stop the eggs from scrambling when adding them to the soup. This keeps the texture smooth and creamy without dairy.

→ Can the soup be prepared in advance?

You can make the broth, chicken, and rice ahead. However, don’t add the egg-lemon mix until serving, as reheating it may cause curdling. If necessary, reheat gently on low.

→ How can I make it thicker?

For a heartier bowl, try adding 1 1/4 cups of rice or swap in orzo. Some versions also include extra egg for more thickness.

→ What pairs well with this dish?

Enjoy it alongside warm pita, a Greek salad, or flaky spinach pies like spanakopita. A light meal can include crusty bread and a simple salad with an olive oil-lemon dressing.

→ Is leftover poultry okay to use?

Yes! Shred about 2 cups of cooked turkey or chicken and add it when the recipe says to include the chicken. It's a great way to use leftovers!