Save
Ever had those days when you can't pick between a pot pie or pizza? That's how these gems happened at my place. After my kids kept bickering for the crusty pizza corners, I figured—why not let everyone have a deep, cheesy pie of their own? Wrapping fillings in a biscuit that's soft and buttery turned out even better than any pizza or pot pie alone. Now, whenever we need quick snacks or have folks over to watch the game, these always hit the spot.
Honestly, my daughter's volleyball crew tore through two trays after their game just yesterday. When those biscuits turn golden and the cheese bubbles up all toasty on each pie, it’s just cozy, happy food at its best.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Pepperoni slices bring the pizza vibes
- Mozzarella shredded thin for gooey cheese pulls
- Pasta sauce—grab your favorite jar
- Butter, real and melty, makes the crust super tasty
- Italian herbs give a nice punch of flavor
- Biscuits from the fridge—keep them cold
- Bit of olive oil for a crisp bake
- Garlic powder for lots of zip
Save
Step-by-Step Directions
- The Final Sprinkle
- One last handful of cheese on top will give you those crunchy edges everyone wants. Seriously, don't even think about skipping this.
- Layering Up
- Now it's fun time. Brush garlic butter everywhere inside each biscuit crust. Then go in this order: sauce first, a bit of cheese, toss your toppings, then some extra cheese at the end. Build it up like teensy towers of yum.
- Biscuit Base
- Pop dough into the muffin pans and press gently so it forms a cup, like a little bowl for all the fillings. Thin and even is best; too thin and they’ll rip, too thick and they won’t bake through.
- Prep Time
- Turn your oven on high and hit up that muffin tin with a solid spray of cooking oil. Don’t skip this or you’ll wrestle cheese stuck to the pan all night!
Awesome Pairings
These pies love sides. I usually throw together a crunchy romaine salad with zippy dressing for balance. If I’m feeling lazy, I warm marinara in a mug and let everyone dunk. And if we’ve got garlic knots, my kids act like it’s a pizza shop at home—pure happiness.
Creative Twists
This is where it gets interesting. The basic idea’s just your starting point—you can tweak it however you like. Sometimes I toss in sautéed peppers and sausage for a ‘fully loaded’ round. My veggie-loving kid packs hers with olives and mushrooms (quick tip: cook mushrooms first so it doesn’t get watery). In summertime, I chop up basil from outside and scatter it on top once they’re done baking.
Storing And Reheating
Let’s be real, we rarely have extras. Still, you can build the pies and keep them in the fridge a few hours before baking. Baked ones last three or four days in the fridge. Want to stash them longer? Cool them down, pop them in the freezer, and you’re good for two months. Warm them back up in the oven so the crust stays crunchy—the microwave makes 'em kinda soggy.
Save
This whole meal started with me playing around in the kitchen and wondering if there was a way to keep everybody at the table happy. Now, it’s our go-to Friday night thing. Teenage appetites, picky eaters, or party crowds—these mini pies are always a win.
Recipe FAQs
- → Can I pick different toppings?
- Absolutely, just stick to dry ones and avoid anything too wet.
- → Why make holes in the dough?
- Poking stops the dough from rising too much while baking.
- → Is it okay to prep these beforehand?
- They're best straight out of the oven, but you can prep early and bake when needed.
- → Do I have to spin the pan?
- Give it a turn for equal baking, especially if your oven has uneven heat spots.
- → What's the best biscuit dough to use?
- Go with regular-store-bought biscuits, but skip the flaky kinds.