Creamy Rice Pudding

Every spoonful of this velvety rice pudding delivers pure comfort, blending the humble charm of rice, milk, and a touch of spice. This laid-back Colombian-inspired treat ditches fancy methods for straightforward homey goodness that'll remind you of grandma's cooking—whether she actually made it for you or not.

When I first whipped this up, my doubtful husband (who swore he hated rice pudding) couldn't help grabbing seconds, then thirds. The subtle vanilla and cinnamon blended with that silky-smooth texture won him over right away. It's now what he asks for most often when the weather turns cold.

Cozy Essential Components

• Medium grain rice builds the foundation with that perfect bite—neither too soft nor too firm, hitting that sweet spot that makes rice pudding so enjoyable
• Milk forms the luxurious base turning ordinary grains into something special—works with any kind, from full-fat to non-fat to plant-based options if you don't want dairy
• Sugar adds just enough sweetness without going overboard—regular white sugar does the job perfectly though you can swap in a quality alternative
• Cinnamon brings that cozy, familiar warmth making each serving feel like comfort in a bowl—sprinkle ground spice for thorough flavor or use a stick for gentle notes
• Vanilla extract (authentic, not synthetic) adds richness that transforms the whole dish—this ingredient truly deserves the good stuff
• Raisins scatter pockets of sweet fruitiness throughout—totally up to you but classically delightful if they're your thing
• Condensed milk might surprise you but it's the hidden hero packing incredible richness and depth
• Butter gives that final luxurious touch tying all flavors together with a smooth finish you'll always want included

Pin it

Soothing Kitchen Magic

Single-Pot Simplicity

Start by throwing your rice, milk, sugar, cinnamon and vanilla into a heavy-bottomed pot together. This straightforward method lets the rice cook right in the flavored milk, soaking up all those wonderful tastes from the start. You won't need multiple pots or pre-cooking—keeping it simple makes all the difference.

Slow Bubbling

Get your mix going with a soft simmer over medium heat, giving it an occasional stir so nothing sticks. Don't crank the heat—aim for tiny bubbles at the edges rather than a full boil. This unhurried approach helps the rice slowly release starch into the milk, creating that signature creaminess without burning.

Take Your Time

Keep cooking, stirring more often as it gets thicker to stop rice from sticking to the bottom. This is relaxed cooking—the kind where you can talk with loved ones, enjoy a warm drink, or just breathe in the wonderful smell filling your kitchen. You'll watch the mixture slowly change before you.

Finishing Flourish

Once the rice feels tender and the mix has thickened how you like it, mix in the condensed milk, butter, and raisins if you want them. These last add-ins turn an already tasty pudding into something unforgettable. The condensed milk brings a sweet, almost caramel-like quality, while butter adds an amazing smoothness.

Pause and Enjoy

Take it off the heat and let your creation sit for a moment before serving. This quick break allows the pudding to settle slightly and lets flavors blend perfectly. Enjoy it warm with maybe a light sprinkle of cinnamon on top, or cool it down for a completely different but equally tasty treat.

I've cooked this pudding during all four seasons, but there's something extra special about making it on wet Sunday afternoons. The windows fog up, that warm vanilla-cinnamon smell fills the air, and suddenly my worries seem smaller. My aunt used to cook this whenever family members felt sick—claiming it worked better than medicine. After she passed down her dedicated pot just for rice pudding, I now use it only for this dish.

Enjoyment Suggestions

Savor this creamy treat straight from the pot for maximum comfort, maybe with a light dusting of extra cinnamon. For breakfast, try cold rice pudding topped with fresh berries or banana slices for a special morning meal that feels fancy but energizes your day. During festive times, serve individual portions in small pretty dishes, topped with a hint of nutmeg and cinnamon stick for a simple yet fancy dessert.

Tasty Twists

Try new flavor combinations by adding orange zest while cooking for a fresh citrus kick that works beautifully with cinnamon. For summer vibes, swap some milk for coconut milk and use chopped mango instead of raisins. In autumn and winter, fold in a spoonful of pumpkin puree with a dash of pumpkin spice for a seasonal change that might become your new favorite.

Keeping It Fresh

Your pudding will stay good in a sealed container in the fridge for up to four days, though at my house it vanishes much faster. If it thickens too much when cold, just add a splash of milk before warming it gently on the stove or in the microwave. For quick snacks, pour into small containers while still warm for grab-and-go treats or breakfasts throughout your week.

Pin it

Smart Cooking Advice

• Always scrape from the bottom as you stir, especially when it thickens, so no rice gets stuck and burns
• Don't try to speed things up—that slow cooking really builds the rich flavor and just-right texture
• Sample before adding final ingredients and adjust sweetness to your liking—everyone has different preferences

In my childhood, this rice pudding was our stormy weather tradition. Mom would start cooking it whenever dark clouds rolled in, and that sweet, warm smell would pull us all to the kitchen like magnets. She taught me to look for when the wooden spoon could stand alone in the pot—that was the sign of perfection. Now with my own family, I find myself reaching for rice whenever it rains, keeping alive a simple custom that somehow brightens any gloomy day. Isn't that really what comfort food should do?

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I switch out the milk for another kind?

Totally! You can use skim, low-fat, or whole milk. Some folks even add a splash of cream for a richer flavor.

→ Is the rice cooked before it goes in?

Nope, start with raw rice. It’s better this way since it soaks up all the flavors as it cooks.

→ I’m not a fan of raisins—can I skip them?

Of course! Leave them out or toss in other dried fruits like cranberries or apricots instead.

→ How do I know it’s ready?

The rice will be soft, and the pudding will be creamy. Don’t worry if it’s a bit runny—it thickens as it cools!

→ Can I eat it cold?

Yep! While it’s great warm, chilled rice pudding is just as tasty. The texture gets thicker in the fridge too.