Save
This glowing green witches brew lemonade is my go-to for Halloween fun. It is bubbly sweet and loaded with lime sherbet froth. My kids love floating gummy worms in every cup and the citrusy punch disappears in minutes at every fall party.
I always make this brew for our trick-or-treat pregame and neighbors look forward to it every year. There is just something magical about serving lemonade that glows and wriggles with gummy worms.
Ingredients
- Lemonade: chilled fresh or store bought for zesty bright flavor pick a lemonade with real juice
- Lemon lime soda: bubbly and sweet use any clear soda for a light finish
- Lime sherbet: adds creamy texture and neon color choose a tart sherbet with real lime for extra tang
- Green food coloring: optional for ultra bright glow pick a gel color for best effect
- Lemon slices: for garnish bring a natural zing and add color
- Lime slices: for garnish double the pucker and visual appeal
- Gummy worms: for garnish perfect for creating a playful creepy look look for soft and brightly colored ones
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Pour In and Chill:
- Add the lemonade to a large pitcher or punch bowl straight from the fridge for best chill
- Mix the Bubbles:
- Gently pour in lemon lime soda stir slowly so you keep the fizz intact without splashing
- Add the Frothy Top:
- Scoop in lime sherbet letting each scoop float on the surface no need to stir sherbet melts slowly and creates a bubbly green cap
- Boost the Glow:
- Drop a few bits of green food coloring around the bowl stir just until the color is evenly electric green
- Garnish with Spookiness:
- Lay lemon and lime slices along the edge of the bowl and hang gummy worms over each glass rim for that haunted party look
- Serve and Enjoy:
- Ladle into glasses or a themed cauldron punch bowl serve right away while frothy and cold
Save
My favorite part about this recipe is the sherbet it creates swirling green clouds that look like a magic potion bubbling up It always amazes me how fast a bowl disappears at our house with kids huddled around asking for gummy worms
Storage tips
This drink is best enjoyed immediately While you can prep the lemonade and soda base ahead and chill it hold off on adding the sherbet and garnishes until just before serving They melt and wilt quickly so last minute is best
Ingredient substitutions
No lime sherbet Try rainbow sherbet or vanilla ice cream for a twist If you want it clearer swap lemon lime sparkling water in for a less sweet but still bubbly treat You can also use orange slices for a citrusy switch
Serving suggestions
Serve it in clear glasses or a big bowl shaped like a cauldron for full Halloween effect Add a black straw or stir stick and tuck in extra gummy worms for the kids Try placing a glow stick under the bowl to make it extra spooky on a dim night
Save
Cultural and festive twist
Witches brew punch is a classic at American Halloween parties It brings all ages together for a bit of silly fun Every time I serve it I am reminded of Halloween gatherings with friends where even grown ups sneak a glass or two
Recipe FAQs
- → Can I use homemade lemonade?
Absolutely! Freshly squeezed lemonade brings a vibrant, zesty flavor to this punch. Adjust sweetness to taste.
- → Is it possible to substitute the lime sherbet?
If lime sherbet isn’t available, lemon sherbet or even lime sorbet provides a similar frothy texture and citrus kick.
- → Will this drink stay fizzy if made in advance?
This punch is best enjoyed fresh. Mix right before serving to maintain the soda's delightful fizziness.
- → What are fun garnish ideas?
Try using citrus wheels, extra gummy candies, or spooky party straws for playful seasonal flair.
- → How can I make this for a large group?
Scale up the ingredients and use a punch bowl or large beverage dispenser. Keep sherbet and garnishes ready until serving.