Save
Folks at my family shindigs basically fight over these Honey Buffalo Crockpot Meatballs now. I ended up making them for my first Super Bowl get-together when I needed something simple but attention-grabbing. Sweet honey teamed up with spicy buffalo sauce is just next level — everyone keeps sneaking another one, even when they're stuffed.
Why Everybody Loves Them
Seriously, you've never had meatballs like these before. Time after time, my pickiest friends go nuts for them. The slow cooker makes the sauce super shiny and sticky while the meatballs turn out juicy every time. I love that they're no-fuss too, so I'm never stuck in the kitchen while my friends have all the fun.
What You'll Need
- Butter: Only real butter works here, trust me.
- Brown Sugar: Just the right amount makes that sticky, sweet finish.
- Honey: Use your good honey for the best flavor.
- Hot Sauce: Frank's is my pick for the ideal heat level.
- Frozen Meatballs: I always have extras ready for last-minute plans.
Jumping In
- Let It Cook
- Now it's just a waiting game. The smell is unreal while it bubbles away.
- Adding Meatballs
- Toss in the frozen meatballs—no thawing, just dump 'em in and relax.
- Making The Sauce
- I like to stir everything up in the slow cooker. It saves dishes, and the honey with butter melts down fast this way.
Total Crowd-Pleaser
Countless parties have been saved by these meatballs. They're always wiped out before anything else. Last Super Bowl, my nephew almost polished off half the crock himself! If that's not a win, I don't know what is.
Save
Switch It Up
Sometimes I shake in a little garlic powder if I'm feeling extra. Once in a while, I'll try a bit of ranch seasoning too. My sister swaps in turkey meatballs and they're awesome that way. Honestly, this one's so easy you can play around with whatever you've got.
Picking Your Heat Level
Everybody's got their own spice limit at my place. My husband piles on even more hot sauce. The kids love things sweeter. I usually keep it middle-ground. That way, everyone can dip and doctor theirs just how they want.
Storing Leftovers
If you don’t gobble them all in one go, stash leftovers in a closed container. They’re awesome the next day too—the sauce thickens up even more in the fridge.
Dip City
I always have ranch and blue cheese on the table for dunking. My friend Lisa brought cilantro lime dip once and wow, it was so good. Don’t skip the dips—they make these even better.
Ultimate Game Day Pick
This is my go-to food for the big game. While everyone else is stuck making fussy snacks, I just start these in the slow cooker and chill. Goes great with a cold beer—there’s never any left after halftime.
Save
Plan Ahead Like A Pro
I like to have the sauce ready a few days early. Pop it in the fridge in a jar, then just pour it over meatballs when you’re set. It’s my little trick for stress-free hosting.
Choosing Meatballs
After trying all kinds, I've learned plain homestyle meatballs soak up the sauce best. Save Italian-flavored ones for your pasta nights instead.
Freezer Friendly
Doubling up and freezing half works perfectly. When company shows up or you need dinner fast, just let 'em thaw overnight in the fridge, then heat and go.
Sweet Tooth Tips
I love how honey and brown sugar mix here, but you can adjust. When it’s chilly, I go heavier on the honey, cut back when it’s hot out. Let your favorite flavors guide you!
Fresh Toppers
Chopped fresh parsley or green onions bring a burst of color and freshness on top. Really makes the dish pop and adds that crisp bite to all the sticky, sweet heat.
Save
Fun Ways To Serve
We eat these over a bowl of rice for dinner, or slide them into mini buns at parties. My daughter’s even tossed them on salads. You’ll keep discovering new tasty combos every time.
Potluck Favorite
I’ve brought these to more potlucks than I can count. They always stay hot in the slow cooker and there’s never any left for me to bring home. That tells you they’re a hit!
Slow Cooker Magic
Honestly, the slow cooker does all the hard work. Simple stuff turns into something special while you do other things. Bonus—it keeps everything warm the whole time you’re celebrating.
Easy Clean-Up Trick
Here’s what I do: spray the slow cooker before you start or grab a liner. The sauce can get sticky—but this hack makes washing up super quick, so you can hang out longer.
Always Gets Rave Reviews
These little guys work for weeknight dinners or a giant bash—never let me down. There’s just something about the sweet and spicy mix; folks always circle back for more. At this point, they're totally part of our family traditions.
Save
Recipe FAQs
- → Can I use other meatballs?
Totally! Try beef, chicken, or turkey meatballs. Just grab the frozen, cooked kind so they hold up in the slow cooker.
- → How many people will it feed?
You'll get about 8 servings at 4 ounces per person. Got a big group? Just double up and you're set.
- → What if I want it less spicy?
Just cut back the hot sauce or swap for something milder. The honey and sugar chill the spice anyway.
- → Is stirring necessary?
You should give it a stir now and then, so everything gets saucy and doesn't scorch on the sides.
- → Can these be done in advance?
Yep, you can keep them warm right in the slow cooker until it's time to serve. Great for getting things ready ahead.