Pin it
I threw these baked pizza wraps together last year when I was stuck for a quick dinner with no regular pizza stuff on hand. The mix of crunchy tortillas loaded with all your favorite pizza stuff makes these wraps taste just like pizza but they're so much easier. They've now become what we grab when we need food on the table in less than half an hour.
When my son's buddy randomly stayed for dinner the night I made these, he wanted the recipe to give his mom. When a teenage boy asks how to make something, you've definitely got a winner!
Basic Components
- Flour tortillas - They get wonderfully crunchy in the oven, making the perfect base
- Pizza sauce - Grab it from the store or use your own if you've got it
- Mozzarella cheese - Gives you that gooey, stretchy pull that makes it feel like actual pizza
- Various toppings - Whatever you'd normally put on pizza works great here
- Italian seasoning - This herb mix gives everything that classic pizza flavor
Pin it
Building Your Wraps
- Picking Tortillas
- Go for the big "burrito size" ones - smaller tortillas won't hold enough stuff. Flour works better than corn since they get crispier for this. If your tortillas seem old or stiff, pop them in the microwave with a damp paper towel for about 10 seconds so they'll bend better. My first try with tiny tortillas was a mess - everything kept falling out while rolling.
- Adding Sauce
- Make sure to spread sauce evenly but leave that empty space around the edge to stop leaks during cooking. I use a spoon back to smooth it out thinly. Too much makes everything soggy, too little and they're dry. About 1/4 cup per wrap seems just right after lots of tries. Sometimes I mix some pesto with my pizza sauce for extra kick.
- Arranging Fillings
- Don't overdo it - less works better here. I chop everything smaller than for normal pizza so it doesn't poke through or make rolling hard. Putting cheese both under and over your toppings helps glue everything together. I always cook mushrooms and watery veggies first to get rid of moisture that could make soggy wraps. Everyone in my house likes different stuff, so I usually make each wrap custom.
- Folding Method
- How you fold makes the difference between neat wraps and a mess. I tuck in the sides first, then roll from bottom to top, keeping it snug. It's just like making a burrito. For wraps that might come undone, I sometimes stick toothpicks in before baking, taking them out before eating. Putting the seam down on the baking sheet helps keep them closed.
- Using Oil
- That olive oil brush might seem small but it's what turns your tortilla super crispy. I use a silicone brush to cover everything evenly, including the sides and ends. The oil also helps them turn that nice golden color. You just need a light coating. I've tried spray oil too but it doesn't taste quite as good.
- Oven Time
- Getting the heat and timing right matters - 375°F crisps the outside without burning before the inside heats up. I start looking at them around 10 minutes since ovens can be different. You want that golden brown look and crispy outside. If they're getting too dark but aren't crisp yet, I turn the heat down to 350°F for a few more minutes. Letting them sit briefly after baking helps the cheese set so it doesn't all run out when you cut them.
My hubby, who's usually picky about his pizza, actually said these were "better than I thought they'd be" and grabbed another one. From someone who normally only wants the real deal, that's pretty big praise for this quick fix.
Tasty Companions
These pizza wraps go great with a basic green salad for an easy weeknight meal. When friends come over, I slice them smaller and put out extra sauce for dipping as a starter. On game days, we have them with other finger foods like wings or veggie sticks. My kids even take them in their lunch boxes next day - they taste fine at room temp too.
Tasty Twists
You can make a morning version with eggs, cheese and bacon bits inside. For something sweet, try Nutella with sliced strawberries and banana, brushed with cinnamon sugar instead of oil. Want a Hawaiian twist? Mix ham, pineapple, and cheese with a bit of BBQ sauce mixed into your pizza sauce. Just last month I tried a Greek style with feta, olives and spinach that turned out amazing.
Pin it
I've brought these pizza wraps to everything from rushed family dinners to kid sleepovers, and they always get eaten up fast. There's just something about that familiar pizza flavor in a fun handheld package that makes meals more exciting. My daughter now helps me make them, coming up with her own topping combos and beaming when everyone loves what she created. Sometimes the best recipes aren't fancy but just simple fixes that answer "what's for dinner?" in a way that makes the whole family happy.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I put these rolls together ahead of time?
- Definitely! Prep them up to a day early, cover, and refrigerate. When baking time comes, oil them and pop them in the oven, but add an extra couple of minutes since they're starting cold.
- → Can I freeze these crispy rolls?
- For sure! Roll them up, wrap them tight in plastic, and store in a freezer bag for up to three months. To bake, take off the wrap, brush with oil, and cook straight from frozen at 375°F for 18-20 minutes.
- → What toppings can I try in these rolls?
- Go wild! Toss in sausage, pineapple, spinach, peppers, or even artichoke hearts. Switch up your cheeses too—melt some provolone, cheddar, or a pizza mix. Just don't overpack them!
- → How do I keep the rolls closed while baking?
- Lay them seam-down on your pan so they stay shut. Toothpicks help too—just pull them out before eating! Brushing a little water on the tortilla edges can also help them seal.
- → Can I make these gluten-free or low-carb?
- Yep! Swap in gluten-free tortillas or give low-carb wraps a try. Lettuce wraps can even work but bake less since they cook faster. Keep in mind, new wraps may need tweaks in time or texture.